Hope and Possibility in a Resettlement Town

Mural by Ben and Bernarda Shahn, Roosevelt, New Jersey

Mural by Ben Shahn, Roosevelt, New Jersey
Roosevelt, New Jersey resident Allan Mallach lectured on the history of the Ben Shahn mural during the town’s 75th anniversary celebration.

Is there room for a utopian vision in these dark economic times? A recent trip to my hometown for its 75th anniversary offered a glimpse into that possibility. Much of my weekend there was spent hearing stories of how the original New Deal vision for Roosevelt, New Jersey, had crumbled. But for me—having attended the local elementary school where a New Deal mural told a story of struggle and persistence—that possibility remains very much alive.

Originally called Jersey Homesteads and renamed Roosevelt in 1945, the tiny borough was one of 99 towns created under the New Deal’s Resettlement Administration, whose broad mission also included relocating migrant laborers as part of an effort to create employment and social stability.

Established in 1937, the town was a test case in greenbelt town planning, with homes inspired by Bauhaus architectural design. Louis Kahn, who later became an internationally recognized architect, was an assistant to Jersey Homesteads principal architect Alfred Kastner. Years later Kahn designed Four Freedoms Park on New York’s Roosevelt Island, an homage to FDR.

Mural by Ben and Bernarda Shahn, Roosevelt, New Jersey

Detail of mural by Ben Shahn
A section of Ben Shahn’s mural in Roosevelt, N.J.’s elementary school depicts the plight of laborers.

Jersey Homelands also was a social experiment among largely working-class Jewish immigrants in creating a collectively managed community; it was the only Jewish resettlement town. Many of the first residents had fled Eastern Europe in the ‘teens for places like Brooklyn, New York and Philadelphia. When they left the city, it was to found what they called an “agro-industrial cooperative.” It was a dream propelled by town founder Benjamin Brown, a Russian immigrant who devoted much of his life to establishing Jewish agricultural cooperatives.

A culture of political organizing permeated the town in its early days. Over the 75th anniversary weekend one member of the original settlement recalled the seemingly endless march of organizational meetings in which his parents took part. He said he would fall asleep to the voices of adults debating–only to wake up the following morning to hear them still at it!

The cooperative experiment did not last long. The garment factory, farm and store that were Jersey Homestead’s economic base transferred to private ownership, and many residents sought work elsewhere or moved away. Some blame disagreements among settlers, but the stories vary.

What has lasted is a concern for preserving the town’s generous open space and unusual architecture. Preservation fights beginning in the late 1990s kept the town’s greenbelt from succumbing to cookie-cutter suburban development. The Bauhaus-inspired, flat-roofed-cinderblock homes always seemed misplaced, given New Jersey’s cold, wet winters. Still, many current residents have retained the Bauhaus feel of their homes.

Roosevelt’s 884 contemporary residents include a thriving artist community through which the town maintains some of the leftward tilt of its original residents. Perhaps it helps that the Roosevelt Public School still boasts the amazing mural by New Deal artist Ben Shahn, whose family lives in town. Depicting the town’s founders and one of its most famous supporters—Albert Einstein—the 1937-38 mural shows attacks on progressive political models while recording the town’s utopian aspirations.

For a story about Roosevelt, New Jersey 75th anniversary, visit https://www.npr.org/2012/09/23/161494490/new-deal-town-turns-75-utopian-ideals-long-gone

[Editors note: An earlier version of this article incorrectly indicated that Albert Einstein lived in Roosevelt. He was a political supporter of the town, which is about 16 miles from the Institute for Advanced Studies in Princeton, NJ, Einstein’s academic home until his death in 1955.]

Sell Berkeley’s Main Post Office? No Way!

Some 3,700 historic buildings across the country are on the chopping block as the US Postal Service moves forward with “realignment” plans. For more details on the fight to save the post offices watch for our October newsletter, coming later this week.

In the meantime, if you are in the San Francisco Bay Area, please save the date for an important hearing where the USPS will take public comment on the fate of Berkeley’s Main Post office, a gorgeous 1915 building that hosts amazing New Deal art.

Be prepared to fill the public record: 7 PM, Tuesday, Nov. 20, 2012.

Can’t make it? You can also send written comments. See below for details.

 

Full text of USPS meeting notice:

“October 24, 2012

Notice of Public Meeting and Comment Period
for Proposed Relocation of Berkeley Post Office

The U.S. Postal Service (USPS) is proposing the relocation of the Berkeley Post
Office, located at 2000 Allston Way.

If the move is approved, there would be no impact on letter carrier delivery to the City’s residents and businesses, and no change to Post Office Box numbers or ZIP Codes, and our goal is to retain all PO Box numbers.

Public input on this proposed relocation is welcome. A public meeting will be held  to explain the proposal and hear comments from 7 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. on Tuesday, November 20, 2012, at the Berkeley Public High School, 1980 Allston Way. The meeting will be held in the High School Auditorium.

Written comments are also being accepted until December 7, 2012. Please submit written comments to:

Diana Alvarado
Facilities Implementation – Pacific Area
U.S. Postal Service
1300 Evans Ave. Ste. 200
San Francisco CA 94188-8200

The reason behind the proposal is the realignment of USPS infrastructure to a 26-percent drop in total mail volume over the past three years, brought about by the diversion to electronic communication and business transactions. USPS does not receive tax dollars for its operations or facilities, but covers costs solely through the revenue received from the sale of its products and services.

The Postal Service is in a very serious financial situation and is facing insolvency.

Every opportunity to reduce expenses and generate revenue is being considered in order to maintain universal service to our customers. If this relocation is approved, USPS anticipates selling the current Berkeley Post Office building.”

Huffington Post: “Romney Rally At Red Rocks Amphitheatre Raises Spectre Of FDR, New Deal”

File this one under New Deal ironies: a candidate running on a shrink-the-government platform, holding a key campaign event in a CCC-built jewel, Colorado’s Red Rocks Amphitheater. Matt Ferner wrote about it this week in the Huffington Post:

“Red Rocks will most definitely serve as a stunning backdrop for what will likely be Romney’s last large-scale rally in the state before Election Day. But as politically innocuous a setting as Red Rocks may seem, its entire existence represents a political philosophy that is in stark contrast to the Romney campaign.

Red Rocks was built by the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), a Depression-era public work relief program under President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s “New Deal” that put unemployed men, ages 17-23, to work. Over a nine year span, the CCC employed 2.5 million young men which provided them with shelter, clothing, food and a small wage.”

Read the rest of Ferner’s commentary here…..

Look at some beautiful photographs of Red Rocks on this blog.

Jon Stewart on Romney, FDR and “Fiscal Responsibility”

If you have a spare 10 minutes, Jon Stewart’s Oct. 9 dissection of the Romney-Ryan fiscal plan offers some food for thought. You can read more about it and watch the three-segment video here. In the third segment, you’ll get a glimpse of a campaign speech from what Stewart jokingly calls “a simpler time,” in which a campaigning Franklin Delano Roosevelt mocks some claims that have a lot in common with the Romney-Ryan proposal. Let us know what you think.

Government is Not a Balance Sheet

 

Susan Ives, of Susan Ives Communications, responds to the Oct. 3 presidential debate:

Romney’s remark about “trickle down government” is pandering to the same segment of society that hated Franklin Delano Roosevelt and that still maligns the New Deal. Meanwhile that same crowd has legions of lobbyists swarming Washington demanding corporate-rancher-agriculture welfare.

Romney’s plan is to resurrect the “trickle down theory” that conservatives cherish, but that led to the chasm between the rich and everybody else. The millionaires have become multimillionaires; multimillionaires have become billionaires. Meanwhile, America’s working class struggles to get by and the poor fall into serfdom.

To what is Romney referring when he sneers about “trickle down government?” Social security for the elderly?  Medicaid for the indigent?  Grants and loans that put college within reach for millions of young people? Regulations that kept rapacious banks and corporations in relative check for more than 70 years?

In reality, the spirit of civic-minded government that the New Deal represents–and that Romney derides–saw millions of Americans through the last Great Depression and built the foundation for our nation’s general prosperity.

President Franklin Roosevelt said, “The test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little.” The measure of government is not a balance sheet, Mr. Romney. Government is about moral leadership that seeks to ensure opportunity and quality of life for all citizens.

Susan Ives is Communications Advisor to the Living New Deal.

[Photo Caption: Images like this one filled the Twitter-sphere this week, playing on Gov. Mitt Romney’s comment about cutting funding for public broadcasting during the Oct. 3 presidential debate. Source: theweek.com]

Vermont Parks: A Legacy Written in Stone

Vermont Public Radio, on uncovering the role of the CCC’s 40,000 New Deal employees in that state: “It’s hard to comprehend the immensity of the Civilian Conservation Corp’s work in Vermont State Parks. At Little River State Park, for example, just below the huge earth-fill dam that creates the Waterbury reservoir was located the largest CCC camp in the East. Earlier this year, park volunteer Ann Imhoff and I walked for about a mile through the woods, seeing old stone chimneys, old foundations and wells. The camp just went on and on. It had churches, a theatre, a hospital, – and was home to more than 3,000 young men who built the huge Waterbury dam. There were more than 40,000 CCC men in Vermont in the mid-1930s, and they made an immense impact on this state.”

Listen: WNYC Radio on the 75th Anniversary of Roosevelt, New Jersey

 

Here’s a nice radio piece on the history of Roosevelt, NJ, one of 99 New Deal resettlement towns. Roosevelt, which turns 75 this year, was unique as an experiment in community planning (it was one of three Greenbelt towns) featuring Bauhaus architecture. It was the only New Deal town that was a cultural and social haven for immigrant Jews from Eastern Europe (who arrived via Brooklyn and Philadelphia). Initially envisioned as a cooperative community, residents took on collective management of the town, its garment factory, store, and farm. The experiments in collective management did not endure, but their history is still evident in the fabric of the tiny town, which also became a center for artists. This radio profile offers a sense of both the lingering mythic history and the realities of life in suburban New Jersey (although it’s economic analysis of the New Deal more broadly is incomplete). We’ll have a first person report soon on the town and its 75th Anniversary celebrations.

Colbert and Grunwald on the Politics of Hope

Michael Grunwald, author of The New New Deal, defended New Deal politics in conversation with Stephen Colbert this week. Colbert, through the voice of his right-wing avatar, confessed that the New Deal gave “hope to a shattered country.” Grunwald offers a comparison between then and now; he defends the 2009 Recovery Act, but says we don’t hear the story of its success because of the way it was carried out. Watch it here — Colbert Report: Sept 5, 2012